Same face, two answers. Here is why.
It is not a bug. The model reads an image, and two images of the same face are never identical.
Updated 2026-10-18
Light alone can move the result
We darkened (×0.6) and brightened (×1.4) 108 test faces without changing anything else. The age group stayed the same in both versions for 83.3 % of faces. In other words, about one face in six changed group from brightness alone. Side light and overhead light, which change shadows rather than overall brightness, are not covered by this test and can weigh more.
Group boundaries
Age groups have hard edges. If your face looks close to 40, a small change can swing the answer between 30-39 and 40-49. That is why the next group is a frequent answer: for adults on our test set, the result is exact 55.6 % of the time and within one group 94.7 % of the time.
Even identical selfies vary
NIST tested six algorithms submitted by developers on the daily self-portraits of artist Noah Kalina, taken with the same camera and the same pose for years. The estimate jumped from day to day, with a standard deviation above two years even for the best algorithm. NIST lists clothing, hair, room lighting and sensor noise as the only short-term changes.
Angle, expression, glasses, beard, make-up
NIST groups these factors in two families: photography (light, exposure, focus, distortion) and presentation (facial hair, glasses, skin, cosmetics). Their effect is not even predictable in direction: with glasses, some algorithms overestimated age while others underestimated it. A big smile, a low angle or a tilted head change the image the model reads.
Image quality
Photos taken quickly with cheap webcams gave generally worse estimates than photos taken at immigration offices in the NIST evaluation. Screenshots, messaging apps and beauty filters add compression and smoothing. Use the original file.
How to compare two photos fairly
- Same place, same time of day, facing the same window.
- Same distance and height, same neutral expression.
- Original files, no filter.
- Check both with the photo comparison tool: it shows which conditions differ before you read anything into the result.
Sources
- Face-Age light stability measurement, 18 October 2026: method and limits.
- NIST IR 8525, Face Analysis Technology Evaluation: Age Estimation and Verification, Hanaoka, Grother et al., May 2024.