Comparison

Cropping a portrait: five tools, one hidden question.

Every tool crops. The difference is elsewhere: does your photo leave your device, and does the cropped file still say where it was taken?

Updated 2026-10-18

How we compared

  • Same test file for every tool: a synthetic image (a grey gradient, no face) carrying fake camera data: brand, model, author, serial number and a GPS position. No real photo was sent anywhere.
  • Two measurements: whether the file leaves the device (network requests recorded during use) and what metadata the cropped file still contains (read back after download).
  • Phone apps could not be tested on our bench: their rows come from Apple’s and Google’s official help pages, and say so.
  • Conflict of interest: one of the five tools is ours. We publish the raw results so you can judge. No tool paid to be here, and there are no affiliate links.

Tests run on 18 October 2026. Tools change: a later version may behave differently.

Results

ToolWhere the photo is processedGPS in the cropped fileFormatsEvidence
Face-Age portrait crop (web)In the browser, no upload requestRemoved1:1, 4:5, 9:16, face centered automaticallyTested
IrfanView 4.67 (Windows)On the computerKept, with author and serial number (default settings)Any rectangle, by handTested
iLoveIMG Crop (web)Sent to the publisher’s servers (upload to api23.iloveimg.com), deleted within two hours according to the publisherKeptAny rectangle, in pixelsTested
iPhone PhotosOn the phoneDepends on how you share: removed only if you turn off Location in the share optionsPresets such as Square, Wallpaper, 9:16, 5:7Apple documentation, not tested
Google PhotosPhone and Google accountLocation can be withheld per shared link or album; a downloaded file keeps the location saved by the cameraNot checkedGoogle documentation, not tested

What the tests show

Cropping does not clean. Two of the three tools we tested returned a cropped image that still contained the GPS position, the author name and the camera serial number. A crop changes the pixels you see, not the data that travels with the file.

“Online” can mean two very different things. iLoveIMG uploads the photo to its servers and sends back the result. Face-Age does the crop in your browser. Both are web pages, and nothing in the interface tells you which is which: only the network log does. You can check it yourself with the method in where does your photo go?

Phone apps leave the choice to you, share by share. On iPhone, Apple documents a Location switch in the share options. In Google Photos, location can be withheld for links and albums, but a downloaded file keeps the position recorded by the camera.

Which one for what

  • A profile picture or a post, quickly: the crop in your phone’s gallery, turning off Location when sharing, or the Face-Age portrait crop, which centers the face and removes metadata.
  • Precise retouching on a computer: a desktop editor such as IrfanView, then a pass through the metadata cleaner before sharing.
  • Avoid for portraits: tools that upload the photo when a local tool does the same job. A face photo is personal data.

Limits of this comparison

One test file, one date, default settings. IrfanView and other editors have options we did not explore; some may remove metadata on export. We did not test cropping quality, speed or ads. The phone rows rely on official documentation, which can lag behind app updates.

Sources